These thoughts follow the latest video in Live Action’s “Mona Lisa Project” exposure of Planned Parenthood abuses, which may be found here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UJt3OVIdhUk.
images from ‘Pieta,’ El Greco
Laws. Why do laws exist? There is no single reason, or perhaps no single way of looking at the complex reason for laws. They are there because we are contingent and fallen — that is, because we make mistakes out of ignorance or malice or, often, some psychologically exhausting combination of the two. Laws are there to teach, to witness to truth in a society, and to uphold that truth. Laws are to protect us from ourselves, from one another, from the various dangers which exist in this world. Laws are to make a space wherein persons can relate to one another in freedom, in truth, in love. There are good laws, poor laws, evil laws, for-a-time laws and work-in-progress laws. But laws are for the wellbeing of the citizens of a nation.
The lawbreaking in this video is heartbreaking. (These videos, I should say, because they are a series … as are the abuses revealed therein.) It is not simply a violation of valid laws themselves and the rule of law in our nation. It is part of a larger violation and sundering of persons. The undercover operation shows a dynamic that goes on in at least some of these clinics across the nation: responsibility towards a minor is abdicated. The young woman, whose vulnerability is expressed in her legal status, is failed by those whose duty of care is to protect her. Failed, because they help her to break the very laws designed to protect her. Failed, because they encourage her to enable the father of her child to continue this relationship which is (a) illegal and (b) has led to a crisis pregnancy — which is damaging at least on these two points, and may be in more ways, and which our nation has deemed “statutory rape” for a reason. Failed, because they sollicitously get her the “paperwork” which is her ticket to sidestep the law and avoid notifying the very people who are responsible, legally and morally, for being the girl’s first protection — and they do this, not because there is any indication of abuse, but to deliver a handy solution to a girl who is, not surprisingly, afraid. This is the lawbreaking side of the larger personbreaking at work here.

Fragmentation. My overall response to what the video shows is, “This is diabolical.” What is the diabolical? What is the nature of this darkness, and how is it at work here? I had a good reminder recently, listening to a discussion on Boethius. Evil, like darkness, is privation. Darkness is an apt metaphor – and it is only a metaphor, albeit a very powerful one, because mystery too can be darkness – because it is the absence of light. Evil is not itself something, but at the same time, in this sublunary world, it is a force to be reckoned with. “A metaphysical parasite,” our discussion leader called it. Or as I tell my students, “The devil doesn’t create; he just goes around smashing things.” This smashing is real, real as the Blood poured out on Calvary (but love is realer), and when we encounter the diabolical we are justly angered and afraid, because what it can do to people is terrible to behold. The diabolical destroys the beautiful, perverts the good, negates the truth, and would sunder into fragments that which is designed to rest in wholeness.
What this video shows is sundering, sundering, sundering. The employees have been sundered from their true calling — they have been trained, somehow, somewhere, to turn their backs and call it helping, like the parents who give a child poison because he seems to want it so. They aren’t comfortable with this. The nervous giggling of the young women, which should be read as a plea for guidance, is echoed in the nervous giggles of the employees who are eager to provide simple cures. Abortion by chemicals? Just a pill. That’ll be so simple… except she is too far along. Abortion by instruments? It won’t hurt. A bit of discomfort… we won’t go into detail. We won’t speak of the sundering that goes on in the womb — sundering of mother and child, sundering of the child itself. It’s okay, really, brush it under the rug, don’t speak of it and it doesn’t really exist, like the girl’s very problems and fear. Statutory rape? Oh, well, don’t bring him into this, then. We won’t speak about it. I didn’t hear it. Parental involvement? That’s the law, true, but we can sidestep that. You don’t want them to know? Here, have some paperwork. With one sweep of forms and pen, we can set up the court between you and your parents in case anything should come up. Easy, easy. Service with a smile.
Fragmented, too, is the very vision of sexuality. Is anyone else unsettled by the way employees speak of sexual anatomy & physiology? On the one hand, nervous giggling about these things is as old as comedy’s acknowledgement of human struggles. There is some true homage paid to bodily awkwardness, sensitivity, even sacredness in those ums and giggles. On the other hand, the employees work to convey that matter-of-factness which helps deal with awkward facts. But it rings false, ominous even. If you are truly addressing women’s health (a woman’s health) in a delicate situation, what is needed is delicacy, gentleness, respect for bodies and so for persons. There is nothing so tasteless as trying to be matter-of-fact about shoving an instrument inside a woman to kill and extract her child by comparing it to sexual union. Or rather, to the isolated part of a man involved in it. Tasteless, heartless, disrespectful, blasphemous. Blind.

Relationships. And what of the girl’s relationships, so critical at a time when she’s so vulnerable? We witness how her relationship to the health care workers is a failure. Her relationship to the child within her is not even addressed. Except… that they do acknowledge this is a difficult time. It would be good for her boyfriend – that father whose child within her speaks of their union – it would be good for him to be there when she has the procedure. Well, hell yeah. It’s a horrific thing. He should be there, to stop it! They don’t believe that, of course. But there is, somewhere in this, a recognition of the unspoken agony, because they do think it would be a good thing for the man to be there with her. Until they discover he’s already committed a crime by sleeping with her. Then he’s best kept out of things. He is not called on to be accountable, though that is the only healthy way to serve the couple’s relationship as well as each of them. The workers only become additional accomplices in helping him to evade responsibility, and ones who don’t have any kind of emotional entanglement to cloud their judgment. Nor do they give the girl’s parents a chance to look out for her. That relationship, too, is treated lightly and legal structures interposed, offhandedly, which would sever the parent-child bond when most it is needed. The girl obviously cares about her relationship with them, otherwise she wouldn’t be worried about them knowing. But now, when she is most vulnerable and most in need of the support which it is their role to offer, she is helped – without question, with reassurance - to distance herself from them. The parents are swept under the rug (illegally), the man is swept under the rug (illegally), and their responsibilities are assumed – at least partially - by these employees who show themselves to be the last people on earth who should be in the position of looking out for the girl.
The darkness shatters. The situation which the video shows - through the meeting of pretense and reality – is a sphere of culture which divides persons from persons in as many ways as there are relationships. Divides, shatters, and leaves everyone sundered. From one another in society, by disregarding laws. From one another in health care, by turning backs on a long tradition of nonviolence and blind eyes to the true needs at hand. From one another as mother-to-child, woman-to-man, child-to-parent. And not only sundered from others but sundered within their very selves. The wounded left and led to further fragmentation.
What we have seen, so far, is a situation without hope. That does not mean things are hopeless. Far from it. There is one more division, already overcome if only we say yes, whose healing heals all others. That reunification is where the hope is, that is what Hope is, and all smaller hopes flow from it and into it and serve its healing cause, whether they know it or no.

Hope there is. But Planned Parenthood, alas, fails to offer it. And therein lies the tragedy.